Shopping for someone who reads mysteries is either very easy or very hard. Easy, because they always want another book. Hard, because they’ve probably already read the one you were going to buy.
So this year I put together a list of gifts you can only get here, in my store. Not on Amazon, not in bookstores. Some are signed, some are printed just for my readers, and a few come with a cup of Charlie’s tea on the side.
I’ve split it into two parts: Gifts for under the tree, and Stocking Stuffers for the little extras.
Gifts
A Mysterious Christmas Gift Box (Store Exclusive)
If you only pick one thing from this list, make it this one. It’s everything you need for a cozy Christmas in Redemption, Wisconsin, packed into one box:
- A Mysterious Christmas Collection, exclusive paperback. This edition is printed only for my store, on heavier paper with a thicker cover, so it’s made for giving and rereading. It has two Christmas mysteries in one book. In Secret Santa Murder, Charlie Kingsley tackles a locked-door case after a party guest is murdered right after opening their gift. In The Mysterious Case of the Dead Elf, Emily and the Redemption Detective Agency go back in time to solve a dead elf mystery and save Christmas. It’s the first time Charlie and Emily appear together, and there are two of family favorite Christmas cookie recipes in the back. (Charlie bakes them as well.)
- A canister of Charlie’s Concoctions tea in the blend you choose: Candy Cane Concoctions, Deep Sleep or Lemon Lavender.
- Our “All I Want for Christmas Is More Books” mug.
- A keepsake book-stack ornament.
Want to make it bigger? You can add The Murder Before Christmas, Three French Hens and a Murder or both, and choose how you’d like the book signed.
Both stories are clean, twisty and funny, short enough to finish in an evening by the tree, and you don’t need to have read either series first.
$59.99 to $84.99, depending on add-ons. Everything ships together in one box. Order by December 16 for delivery before Christmas.
The Charlie’s Concoctions Starter Pack (Christmas)
Charlie has strong opinions about tea. Not about which tea (that depends on you, your day and whatever Redemption has put you through lately), but about how you make it: good loose leaf, properly steeped, in a proper mug.
This kit has everything you need to do it right from the first cup:
- One tin of loose leaf tea. Choose Candy Cane Concoctions (Charlie’s Christmas blend: bold black tea with real candy cane pieces and peppermint), Lemon Lavender (her most popular blend) or Deep Sleep.
- A 12 oz Charlie’s Concoctions mug, printed on both sides.
- A mini tea ball, so they can start steeping right away.
It’s a perfect gift for the tea lover, the reader or anyone who could use a calmer December.
$39.99
The “All I Want For Christmas is Books” Christmas Gingerbread Mug
If you just want our “All I Want for Christmas is Books” mug, here it is. It’s an 11 oz white ceramic mug, safe for the dishwasher and the microwave (although it might be better to hand-wash to make sure the design doesn’t fade).
$14.99
Murder Mystery Games
For the reader who always guesses the killer by chapter three, give them a case to solve themselves.
Each game is a case file from the Redemption Detective Agency, full of clues like journal entries, letters, detective notes, maps and newspaper clippings. Your job is to figure out who did it. Play alone, with family over the holidays or with your book club. You don’t need to have read the books.
Choose a download (a PDF with all the clues) or a mailed physical case file, with free shipping.
The Christmas pick: The Mysterious Case of Merry Bell. In 1982, Merry Bell was found dead in her kitchen the night before the big gingerbread house competition, hit over the head with a rolling pin. Everyone assumed her biggest rival, Goldie Tinsel, did it, but the police could never prove it. Now Goldie wants her name cleared. Are you up for it?
For serious sleuths, there are bundles too:
- The Redemption Detective Agency 3-Game Bundle (from $19.99)
- The Complete Murder Mystery Game Bundle, all five cases: Henrietta Beechwood, Tom Turkei, Merry Bell, Tippy Goodyear and Crystal Cox (from $29.99)
Signed Paperbacks, Hardbacks and Large Print
Every paperback and hardback from my store is signed by me and comes with swag. That’s something no other store can give you.
When you order, you can choose how you’d like it signed:
- Author’s Choice, where I write a little something
- Author’s Name Only
- Custom, where you tell me what to write (perfect for a gift: “To Mom, Merry Christmas!”)
- None, if you’d rather leave it unsigned
Many titles also come in large print, a thoughtful choice for a reader who’d like a little more comfort on the page.
A few Christmas-themed places to start:
- The Murder Before Christmas, Charlie Kingsley Book 1. A pregnant wife jokes about poison, and then her cheating husband turns up dead on Christmas Eve.
- Three French Hens and a Murder, a Charlie Kingsley holiday novella.
Or give them a whole series at once and save:
- The Charlie Kingsley Mysteries: Books 1–4 Bundle
- The Redemption Detective Agency Book Bundle
- The Secrets of Redemption 3-Book Paperback Bundle: Starter Pack
Stocking Stuffers
Keepsake Ornaments (Coming Soon)
A keepsake ornament for the reader’s tree. These are coming to the store soon, so keep an eye out. (If you can’t wait, one comes inside A Mysterious Christmas Gift Box.)
Miniature Books
These little spiral-bound 5″ x 7″ paperbacks fit perfectly in a stocking, and each one is a complete story the reader can finish on Christmas afternoon. $5.99 each.
A Grave Error, a Charlie Kingsley cozy novella. Charlie is NOT a doctor, but that doesn’t stop a customer from calling her in the middle of the night because her daughter was attacked by… a gargoyle? There’s no such thing as gargoyles… right? (Also available in a spiral-bound large print edition for $7.99.)
Today I’ll See Her, a Riverview psychological thriller short story. Every day, Sissy goes to the same restaurant at the same time and orders the same thing. No one knows why, until a stranger from a mysterious, haunted town arrives. For the reader who likes their stocking stuffers a little unsettling.
The Secret Diary of Helen Blackstone, from the Secrets of Redemption series. In 1929, Helen is forced to return to her childhood home, a place full of secrets and lies, where her mother went mad. When her brother is threatened, she uncovers a truth that changes everything.
Happy Holidays from Redemption
Every gift on this list comes straight from me, and most of them you simply can’t find anywhere else. Thank you for making my books part of your holidays.
And don’t forget: order by December 16 for delivery before Christmas.


